Arne Duncan, Larry Summers, As Well As The Higher Pedagogy Myth

I am currently working on a book, The Politics of Higher Education, Jobs, in addition to Inequality.  One of my psyche arguments is that at that topographic point is a bipartisan consensus that higher educational activity is the solution to all of our economical in addition to social problems.  There are several problems amongst this stance: 1) producing to a greater extent than people amongst college degrees does non create to a greater extent than goodness jobs; 2) higher educational activity itself magnifies economical in addition to social inequality; 3) political officials focus on higher educational activity hence they don’t accept to verbalize well-nigh underemployment, exploitive task practices, globalization, automation, de-unionization, de-professionalization, privatization, poverty, the minimum wage, in addition to social welfare programs; in addition to 4) the belief inwards higher educational activity equally a fair meritocracy serves to justify inequality. 

These myths surrounding higher educational activity in addition to the economic scheme were on total display during debate betwixt Jill Lepore in addition to Clayton Christensen, Summers argued that technology scientific discipline volition forcefulness schools to either conform or die.  He added that since the average professor is around fifty, these institutions volition non experiment because all of the novel technology scientific discipline companies are led past times immature people.  The implied solution hence is to acquire rid of tenure in addition to shared governance in addition to allow these schools experiment in addition to innovate.   What Summers did non say is that these institutions accept already innovated past times replacing professors amongst part-time, non-tenured faculty.

While the electrical flow President of Harvard, Drew Faust, did force dorsum on some of Summer’s ideas, she said that faculty would last much happier if they spent their fourth dimension on their ain practiced areas in addition to did non waste product fourth dimension on learning well-nigh schoolhouse budgets in addition to other issues concerning shared governance.  In other words, she likewise believes that shared governance should last handed over to the practiced administrators who locomote along to multiply on our campuses.  

Like Duncan, Summers believes that it makes no feel to accept 35,000 professors learn calculus at their private schools when a minor number of swell professors could learn thousands online.  Under the banner of increasing equality of opportunity, Summers wants to eliminate most of the faculty.  Here nosotros run into ane of the ways that higher education, jobs, in addition to inequality are linked:  technology scientific discipline allows managers to supervene upon workers in addition to growth inequality past times allowing a few stars to brand all of the money.  Of course, the whole sentiment of stars is based on the meritocratic sentiment that nosotros tin give notice fairly guess in addition to assess quality.  In the wishing to plow every human face of our lives into a market, the myth of the fair meritocracy plays the Darwinian locomote of sorting social club into a minor number of winners in addition to a large number of losers, in addition to higher educational activity has similar a shot locomote on of the psyche sources for this generation of inequality.   

Share this post