What Jerry Chocolate-Brown Is Actually Thinking
Sunday, July 6, 2008
Edit
The LA Times Blog has a long unedited, monologue yesteryear Governor Jerry Brown that gives a groovy bargain of insight into this complicated figure. In damage of the University of California, ane number that is discussed is why he has non appointed 3 regents. Brown has the next to say on this of import topic: “I haven’t appointed anyone to the regents yet. Well, who should I appoint? That’s a practiced question. What are they going to do? I’ve appointed unopen to people to the Cal State together with I’ve appointed unopen to interesting people on the dry reason board together with I’m looking, but what impact does that make? If y'all desire to brand change, tin terminate the dry reason board brand an impact? Can the Cal State brand an impact? Things are really conservative inwards how they run. Before when I used to dice to the regents, I’d dice armed together with I was attacking. But it’s totally marginal. You can’t influence ... So straight off it takes to a greater extent than time, you’ve got to live on to a greater extent than subtle, y'all yell for to a greater extent than allies. You yell for a long-term game plan.” In short, Brown seems to live on maxim that he has non appointed anyone since the board is therefore conservative or insulated from whatever influence, including the influence of the governor.
Brown adds that it is difficult to brand whatever choices because of the yell for to cater to therefore many involvement groups agency that the effects are ever watered down: “I also know these boards are non affected yesteryear ane or 2 people, therefore there’s no rush. There are a lot of people I know. Blum I know, the lady who’se the president, she was the president of ane of the painting studios. They’ve got people there. But I’m looking for unlike … But I know that 3 appointments can’t brand (a difference). It truly takes ten. But yesteryear the fourth dimension y'all acquire to ten, together with y'all head to this grouping together with that group, together with I gotta receive got tending of that together with y'all receive got variety together with this influence individual – yesteryear the fourth dimension y'all acquire your x people, they’re therefore unlike that y'all receive got no impact anyway. So this thought that y'all tin terminate influence yesteryear your appointees, y'all receive got to receive got tending of all your diverse constituencies together with therefore y'all terminate upward replicating what is. And that’s why things don’t modify really much. . . If y'all desire to do something that y'all know is practiced but is different, the terminal house you’re going to acquire it done is UC. The minute to terminal house you’re going to acquire it done is Cal State. And the house to a greater extent than probable would live on the community colleges, because they’re to a greater extent than flexible.”
Not exclusively does the governor yell back that appointing 3 novel regents mightiness receive got no existent effect, but he also wonders if x novel regents would modify anything.
It should live on clear that someone has to convince the governor nigh the importance of having regents who truly know nigh universities together with higher education. However, Brown does non seem motivated to modify things fifty-fifty though he realizes that in that location are many problems amongst the electrical current higher ed system.
Part of Brown’s reluctance to appoint novel UC regents tin terminate live on traced to his post-ideological persuasion of government: “you receive got ane grouping that says the reply is to meet authorities every bit the employment together with block it together with seek to trim down it every bit much every bit y'all can. And the other says the employment is the accumulation of working capital missive of the alphabet together with the ability of corporations together with what nosotros yell for to do is strenghthen the manus of authorities together with dice far to a greater extent than intrusive, to a greater extent than invasive together with to a greater extent than impactful therefore every bit to attain to a greater extent than good being. And that’s truly the choice…” By tying the liberal persuasion of authorities to the thought that authorities is perceived every bit existence intrusive together with invasive, Brown shows how many contemporary Democrats receive got bought into the conservative demonization of “big Government.”
Yet, Brown is also aware of how misinformed citizens are nigh the ways governments pass their money: “What makes the selection difficult is in that location is this zone of authorities waste matter which I receive got seen polling suggest people yell back is 40 percnet. Well, 40 perent of a ninety billion full general fund is 36 billion. So in that location is a 36 billion dollar banking company of waste matter that the public wants us to pass earlier nosotros cutting universities, elderly, roads police, all other stuff. Because of that relatively widespread belief … people say why should I pay for a taxation fifty-fifty though it is non on me or it is really trivial when nosotros receive got this banking company nosotros tin terminate dice to. Go pass the waste matter bank. And the employment is the waste matter banking company is non available. It’s window is non opened upward inwards a mode that I tin terminate access.” From his pragmatic perspective, Governor Brown realizes that people yell back in that location is a huge puddle of hidden or wasted resources, which the authorities tin terminate usage if it wants to.
While Brown knows that the public is misinformed, he does non appear to live on willing to usage his compass to educate the people of California together with permit them know the truth nigh the state’s finances. Just every bit inwards the representative of the University of California, this is where nosotros yell for real, bold leadership to clarify the truth together with to advise an effective alternative. At ane point, inwards this interview, he does demo a recognition nigh unopen to of the problems facing the university, but he before long backs away yesteryear returning to the number of governmental waste: “I yell back they tin terminate do it to a greater extent than efficiently at the university. I’ve got a whole majority showing how the academy is spending coin it doesn’t receive got to. Certain kinds of research, sports, gardeners, a lot of things. But in that location isn’t a waste matter banking company of 36 billion inwards California. Not fifty-fifty close.” This is a foreign gratuitous association: the governor jumps from discussing how the academy spends its coin to the inquiry of perceived authorities waste matter every bit if the 2 are the same thing. He appears to live on maxim that since rumors of authorities waste matter are wrong, therefore the analysis of how universities pass coin on expensive side-projects must also live on wrong.
In unopen to other give-and-take of academy spending, Brown repeats his conflicted sense of spending together with waste: “Does a chancellor yell for 350,000? 500,000? I don’t yell back y'all do. Well is that a waste? Well if y'all paying to a greater extent than than y'all need, it is a waste. But therefore they say the marketplace is that together with if nosotros don’t pay it, nosotros don’t acquire it.” While Brown clearly sees the employment amongst paying administrators excessive salaries, he also entertains the university’s claim that they tin terminate exclusively attract together with retain splendid people yesteryear offering them marketplace value. What Brown does non inquire hither is why it is exclusively star administrators who are deemed worthy of market-based salaries. Like therefore many contemporary Democrats, Brown has internalized both the gratuitous marketplace rhetoric of the Right together with the liberal discourse of a meritocracy where exclusively the elites are entitled to a practiced wage.
In unopen to ways, Brown is also aware of how unopen to people persuasion the government, together with his line of piece of work concern for these views limits his political vision: “Everywhere y'all dice human institutions receive got flaws. But hither is the relevant request here: authorities is perceived every bit unique inwards the flaws that it has. And in that location is a for certain hostility. Government has dice the object people tin terminate await to every bit the origin of our suffering together with our problems together with inwards that context it is difficult to acquire people to say gee give to a greater extent than coin to this entity y'all meet every bit the motility of suffering or dysfunction.” While it is clear that the forty-year attempt of the Republicans to demonize the authorities has been really effective, shouldn’t someone similar Governor Brown piece of work to counter this narrative?
It is clear that Brown is plagued yesteryear his shrewd awareness of how competing interests block whatever existent modify inwards politics: “There is no procedural quick fix…We don’t alive inwards unopen to immaculate basis amongst no stain of interest. Everybody is interested. ..Everybody looks to meet how the rules favor their interest. So in that location is no neutral grouping here. Not similar constitutional convention of our founding fathers. We receive got a constitution. We receive got a legislature. We receive got tens of thousands of laws together with practices. You tin terminate exclusively brand a few changes. Any modify y'all make, if y'all dice ane mode perhaps case lawyers similar it. If y'all dice ane way, perhaps insurance companies together with doctors similar it. There is no quick slowly large fix. It is incremental. Step yesteryear step.” Perhaps this pragmatic approach is appropriate for “normal” times, but inwards our electrical current crisis, nosotros yell for something on the club of FDR’s New Deal to truly brand a difference.
In ane of his most telling gratuitous associations, Brown discusses his key thinking nigh education: “One thing, good it’s non like, for example, lets receive got STAR tests. Steinberg doesn’t similar it. Wants to trim down the STAR test. So inwards ane mode I similar the STAR examine because the kids gotta know arithmetic, they receive got to know how to write, they gotta know unopen to English, they receive got to know science. So that’s somewhat mechanical. But on the other hand, every private has unlike interests. I yell back it’s of import that people dice to schoolhouse together with they larn history, they larn philosophy, they larn music. They don’t acquire trained, but they acquire exposed to a much bigger world. So this is an issue: How much should live on training, lockstep, standardization, create amount inwards the blank together with anyone who deviates from that is bad. There’s a chip of that coming out of Washington. On the other manus if you’re therefore lax together with y'all exactly chit-chat inwards class, that’s bad too.” Once again, the governor is conflicted over the principal competing narratives that surroundings teaching inwards the United States. While he is rightly critical of standardized tests together with standardized teaching, he also wants to brand for certain that students larn the basics together with that teachers do non pass their fourth dimension merely gratuitous associating inwards class.
This conflicted persuasion of teaching is matched amongst Brown’s awareness of how learning together with teaching involve therefore much to a greater extent than than memorizing together with testing: “I had a teacher, Mr. McCurdy he afterwards joined the Jesuits. One of his questions on ane of our exams was, I desire y'all to write your impression of a dark-green leaf. OK. I wrote something pretty banal. And I’ve been thinking every fourth dimension I walk out hither together with I await at these dark-green leaves, what’s my impression? Am I exactly dead? What tin terminate I feel? So he created a thought nigh imagination, impression, y'all can’t compass that on a STAR test.” Here, Brown shows himself to live on a deep together with creative thinker who has profited from a creative together with independent teacher.
Perhaps what nosotros larn from this gubernatorial gratuitous association is that the governor is a non-ideological politico who is both opened upward to competing discourses together with crippled yesteryear his awareness. We also know from the mode that students together with unions pushed his taxation initiatory inwards a much to a greater extent than progressive direction that collective activeness tin terminate promote positive social change. It is clear that if nosotros desire something to modify inwards this state, nosotros volition receive got to live on the motivating force.
Brown adds that it is difficult to brand whatever choices because of the yell for to cater to therefore many involvement groups agency that the effects are ever watered down: “I also know these boards are non affected yesteryear ane or 2 people, therefore there’s no rush. There are a lot of people I know. Blum I know, the lady who’se the president, she was the president of ane of the painting studios. They’ve got people there. But I’m looking for unlike … But I know that 3 appointments can’t brand (a difference). It truly takes ten. But yesteryear the fourth dimension y'all acquire to ten, together with y'all head to this grouping together with that group, together with I gotta receive got tending of that together with y'all receive got variety together with this influence individual – yesteryear the fourth dimension y'all acquire your x people, they’re therefore unlike that y'all receive got no impact anyway. So this thought that y'all tin terminate influence yesteryear your appointees, y'all receive got to receive got tending of all your diverse constituencies together with therefore y'all terminate upward replicating what is. And that’s why things don’t modify really much. . . If y'all desire to do something that y'all know is practiced but is different, the terminal house you’re going to acquire it done is UC. The minute to terminal house you’re going to acquire it done is Cal State. And the house to a greater extent than probable would live on the community colleges, because they’re to a greater extent than flexible.”
Not exclusively does the governor yell back that appointing 3 novel regents mightiness receive got no existent effect, but he also wonders if x novel regents would modify anything.
It should live on clear that someone has to convince the governor nigh the importance of having regents who truly know nigh universities together with higher education. However, Brown does non seem motivated to modify things fifty-fifty though he realizes that in that location are many problems amongst the electrical current higher ed system.
Part of Brown’s reluctance to appoint novel UC regents tin terminate live on traced to his post-ideological persuasion of government: “you receive got ane grouping that says the reply is to meet authorities every bit the employment together with block it together with seek to trim down it every bit much every bit y'all can. And the other says the employment is the accumulation of working capital missive of the alphabet together with the ability of corporations together with what nosotros yell for to do is strenghthen the manus of authorities together with dice far to a greater extent than intrusive, to a greater extent than invasive together with to a greater extent than impactful therefore every bit to attain to a greater extent than good being. And that’s truly the choice…” By tying the liberal persuasion of authorities to the thought that authorities is perceived every bit existence intrusive together with invasive, Brown shows how many contemporary Democrats receive got bought into the conservative demonization of “big Government.”
Yet, Brown is also aware of how misinformed citizens are nigh the ways governments pass their money: “What makes the selection difficult is in that location is this zone of authorities waste matter which I receive got seen polling suggest people yell back is 40 percnet. Well, 40 perent of a ninety billion full general fund is 36 billion. So in that location is a 36 billion dollar banking company of waste matter that the public wants us to pass earlier nosotros cutting universities, elderly, roads police, all other stuff. Because of that relatively widespread belief … people say why should I pay for a taxation fifty-fifty though it is non on me or it is really trivial when nosotros receive got this banking company nosotros tin terminate dice to. Go pass the waste matter bank. And the employment is the waste matter banking company is non available. It’s window is non opened upward inwards a mode that I tin terminate access.” From his pragmatic perspective, Governor Brown realizes that people yell back in that location is a huge puddle of hidden or wasted resources, which the authorities tin terminate usage if it wants to.
While Brown knows that the public is misinformed, he does non appear to live on willing to usage his compass to educate the people of California together with permit them know the truth nigh the state’s finances. Just every bit inwards the representative of the University of California, this is where nosotros yell for real, bold leadership to clarify the truth together with to advise an effective alternative. At ane point, inwards this interview, he does demo a recognition nigh unopen to of the problems facing the university, but he before long backs away yesteryear returning to the number of governmental waste: “I yell back they tin terminate do it to a greater extent than efficiently at the university. I’ve got a whole majority showing how the academy is spending coin it doesn’t receive got to. Certain kinds of research, sports, gardeners, a lot of things. But in that location isn’t a waste matter banking company of 36 billion inwards California. Not fifty-fifty close.” This is a foreign gratuitous association: the governor jumps from discussing how the academy spends its coin to the inquiry of perceived authorities waste matter every bit if the 2 are the same thing. He appears to live on maxim that since rumors of authorities waste matter are wrong, therefore the analysis of how universities pass coin on expensive side-projects must also live on wrong.
In unopen to other give-and-take of academy spending, Brown repeats his conflicted sense of spending together with waste: “Does a chancellor yell for 350,000? 500,000? I don’t yell back y'all do. Well is that a waste? Well if y'all paying to a greater extent than than y'all need, it is a waste. But therefore they say the marketplace is that together with if nosotros don’t pay it, nosotros don’t acquire it.” While Brown clearly sees the employment amongst paying administrators excessive salaries, he also entertains the university’s claim that they tin terminate exclusively attract together with retain splendid people yesteryear offering them marketplace value. What Brown does non inquire hither is why it is exclusively star administrators who are deemed worthy of market-based salaries. Like therefore many contemporary Democrats, Brown has internalized both the gratuitous marketplace rhetoric of the Right together with the liberal discourse of a meritocracy where exclusively the elites are entitled to a practiced wage.
In unopen to ways, Brown is also aware of how unopen to people persuasion the government, together with his line of piece of work concern for these views limits his political vision: “Everywhere y'all dice human institutions receive got flaws. But hither is the relevant request here: authorities is perceived every bit unique inwards the flaws that it has. And in that location is a for certain hostility. Government has dice the object people tin terminate await to every bit the origin of our suffering together with our problems together with inwards that context it is difficult to acquire people to say gee give to a greater extent than coin to this entity y'all meet every bit the motility of suffering or dysfunction.” While it is clear that the forty-year attempt of the Republicans to demonize the authorities has been really effective, shouldn’t someone similar Governor Brown piece of work to counter this narrative?
It is clear that Brown is plagued yesteryear his shrewd awareness of how competing interests block whatever existent modify inwards politics: “There is no procedural quick fix…We don’t alive inwards unopen to immaculate basis amongst no stain of interest. Everybody is interested. ..Everybody looks to meet how the rules favor their interest. So in that location is no neutral grouping here. Not similar constitutional convention of our founding fathers. We receive got a constitution. We receive got a legislature. We receive got tens of thousands of laws together with practices. You tin terminate exclusively brand a few changes. Any modify y'all make, if y'all dice ane mode perhaps case lawyers similar it. If y'all dice ane way, perhaps insurance companies together with doctors similar it. There is no quick slowly large fix. It is incremental. Step yesteryear step.” Perhaps this pragmatic approach is appropriate for “normal” times, but inwards our electrical current crisis, nosotros yell for something on the club of FDR’s New Deal to truly brand a difference.
In ane of his most telling gratuitous associations, Brown discusses his key thinking nigh education: “One thing, good it’s non like, for example, lets receive got STAR tests. Steinberg doesn’t similar it. Wants to trim down the STAR test. So inwards ane mode I similar the STAR examine because the kids gotta know arithmetic, they receive got to know how to write, they gotta know unopen to English, they receive got to know science. So that’s somewhat mechanical. But on the other hand, every private has unlike interests. I yell back it’s of import that people dice to schoolhouse together with they larn history, they larn philosophy, they larn music. They don’t acquire trained, but they acquire exposed to a much bigger world. So this is an issue: How much should live on training, lockstep, standardization, create amount inwards the blank together with anyone who deviates from that is bad. There’s a chip of that coming out of Washington. On the other manus if you’re therefore lax together with y'all exactly chit-chat inwards class, that’s bad too.” Once again, the governor is conflicted over the principal competing narratives that surroundings teaching inwards the United States. While he is rightly critical of standardized tests together with standardized teaching, he also wants to brand for certain that students larn the basics together with that teachers do non pass their fourth dimension merely gratuitous associating inwards class.
This conflicted persuasion of teaching is matched amongst Brown’s awareness of how learning together with teaching involve therefore much to a greater extent than than memorizing together with testing: “I had a teacher, Mr. McCurdy he afterwards joined the Jesuits. One of his questions on ane of our exams was, I desire y'all to write your impression of a dark-green leaf. OK. I wrote something pretty banal. And I’ve been thinking every fourth dimension I walk out hither together with I await at these dark-green leaves, what’s my impression? Am I exactly dead? What tin terminate I feel? So he created a thought nigh imagination, impression, y'all can’t compass that on a STAR test.” Here, Brown shows himself to live on a deep together with creative thinker who has profited from a creative together with independent teacher.
Perhaps what nosotros larn from this gubernatorial gratuitous association is that the governor is a non-ideological politico who is both opened upward to competing discourses together with crippled yesteryear his awareness. We also know from the mode that students together with unions pushed his taxation initiatory inwards a much to a greater extent than progressive direction that collective activeness tin terminate promote positive social change. It is clear that if nosotros desire something to modify inwards this state, nosotros volition receive got to live on the motivating force.