Brown Threatens To Double Uc Tuition
Friday, December 18, 2020
Edit
Governor Brown predicts that if the state does non top taxation extensions inwards June, tuition for in-state University of California students could larn from $12,000 to $20,000 or fifty-fifty $25,000 adjacent year. This claim shows that Brown has bought into President Yudof’s rhetoric, in addition to instantly both are using the same misguided strategy. As I have got argued inwards the past, Yudof believes that his entirely agency of working alongside the state is to threaten Sacramento alongside cutting enrollments or raising tuition. The halt number of this strategy is that students e'er suffer, in addition to the UC does non have got to await at its ain internal issues.
In contrast to pop belief, the UC brings inwards extra revenue for each pupil it enrolls, in addition to therefore, it makes no financial or educational feel to cut back enrollments. In fact, I have got lately presented to the Office of the President a novel calculation of how much the UC profits from each additional student. While I have got non heard dorsum from UCOP yet, my calculations present that the direction has been misrepresenting UC’s financial condition to non entirely Earth in addition to the state, but too to the Regents. As yous volition read below, virtually all of the statistics that UCOP presented at the concluding Regents coming together regarding pupil enrollment in addition to finances are agency off the mark, in addition to this information has led some Regents to believe that the UC tin only surrender on state funding. Moreover, the same faulty information is beingness used past times the Governor to threaten a doubling of pupil tuition.
How Much Does the State Really Give the UC Per Student
The University of California direction oftentimes argues that the state back upward for UC students has gone downwards past times over 50% inwards the concluding xx years, but looking at the actual enrollment in addition to funding numbers (the sources are listed at the halt of this entry), nosotros abide by that the per pupil state funding inwards 1990 was $13,690 (there were 156,000 students in addition to the state gave the UC $2.1 billion). In 2010-11, the per pupil state funding is $15,000 (200,00 resident students in addition to the state funding is $3 billion). In terms of pupil fees in addition to tuition, the UC volition have this twelvemonth $1.9 billion inwards tuition in addition to fees (after paying out financial aid), in addition to at that topographic point are 215,000 students (resident in addition to non resident, graduate, undergraduate, in addition to professional); thus the electrical flow per pupil tuition revenue is $8,267. If the state reduces its back upward to $2.1 billion, which is what the Governor is threatening volition hand off if taxation extensions are non passed, the per pupil state back upward volition hold upward just over $10,000, in addition to the total revenue per pupil volition hold upward most $19,000. Furthermore, if the UC gets $2.6 billion from the state, the per pupil back upward for resident undergraduate in addition to graduate students volition hold upward $13,000. In whatever case, it is wrong to tell that students volition hold upward paying to a greater extent than than the state. In fact, currently, the UC is scheduled to have $21,260 per pupil inwards combined state funds in addition to pupil tuition (this is based on state back upward of $2.6 billion). If nosotros add together inwards an average of $2,080 per pupil out of the full general fund, this gives a total of $23,340 of revenue per pupil (the UCOP 2011-12 budget presentation graph puts this number at $17,220). As I told members of the UCOP budget staff, past times downplaying these numbers, the direction motivates Regents to claim that nosotros tin only walk away from state funding.
How Much Profit Does UC Make on Each Additional Student?
I have got too showed UCOP how the worst affair the UC could practice is to decrease its undergraduate enrollments because my analysis shows that UC makes a net off of undergraduate pupil it enrolls. According to UC’s ain numbers inwards its accountability report, inwards 2007-08, at that topographic point were 3,008 Lecturers (average twenty-four hr menstruation of the month was 51%) representing 1,550 full-time equivalent positions (fte), in addition to they generated 1,554 pupil credit hours per lecturer fte at a terms of $34 per pupil credit hr (the average lecturer FTE salary was $54,000 inwards 2009-10). (I am using the most recent salary information from 2009-2010 in addition to the most recent pupil credit hr data, which is from 2007-08. If anything, faculty are teaching to a greater extent than pupil credit hours now, so my calculations are highly conservative).
If nosotros instantly await at senate faculty, inwards 2007-08, at that topographic point were 10,150 senate faculty FTE averaging 445 pupil credit hours per fte. Senate fauclty had an average salary of $110,000 in addition to terms $247 per pupil credit (student credit hours are a superior agency of calculating terms because they takes into work concern human relationship course of study size in addition to course of study units). Last year, undergraduate students averaged 45 credit hours per year, in addition to since 2 thirds of the pupil credit hours are taught past times senate faculty, nosotros tin calculate that the total straight instructional terms is $7,920; it terms $7,410 for senate faculty to generate thirty pupil credit hours in addition to $510 for lecturers to create xv pupil credit hours. If nosotros add together 20% of salary for benefits, nosotros larn $9,504. (This number is high because one-half of the lecturers practice non larn benefits, in addition to the senate faculty who learn most of the undergraduate courses practice non brand equally much equally the senate faculty teaching to a greater extent than oftentimes than non graduate courses. Also, UC does non count courses taught past times graduate students in addition to instead oftentimes credits graduate pupil taught courses to senate faculty who are the teachers of record, in addition to this inflates the terms since graduate students larn so much less coin than senate faculty).
Using the conservative instructional terms of $9,504 in addition to the electrical flow revenue per pupil of $23,340 (calculated above), the UC generates $13,836 per pupil to pay for related in addition to unrelated costs. It is clear that due to the economies of scale, each fourth dimension yous add together to a greater extent than students, yous practice non hire some other administrator or pay to a greater extent than for utilities, the library, or maintenance, in addition to so it makes no financial feel to cut back enrollments, particularly for lower-division undergraduates who are past times far the to the lowest degree costly students. Also, if yous cut back enrollments, yous practice non have got downwards libraries or halt paying your electrical bills.
Now, if nosotros desire to figure the indirect terms per student, 1 agency to practice this would hold upward to determine how much each campus spends on its center mission. For instance, the UCLA College spends 70% of its full general funds budget on faculty salaries in addition to benefits (this includes senate faculty, lecturers, in addition to grad students) in addition to 16% on staff in addition to 11% on operational expenditures, so the indirect terms is 27-30%. If nosotros have got the conservative indirect terms of 30%, in addition to nosotros add together it to my straight instructional terms per pupil of $9,504, in addition to so the total terms is instantly $12,355. Once again, it makes no financial feel for the UC to cut back enrollment since it brings inwards an extra $10,985 per undergraduate student. In the illustration of nonresident students, the UC brings inwards an extra $23,450 per student. Even if the state decides to cut back UC funding past times a billion dollars adjacent year, the UC volition withal pick out inwards a net of $8,000 per student.
While I am withal working difficult to larn the state non to cutting the UC budget, I too recognize that most of the UC’s financial problems are internal. The quandary is that fifty-fifty though it is irrational for the UC to double tuition if the state doubles its budget cut, I believe this is just what volition hand off because no 1 is dealing alongside actual numbers. We all take away to human face upward the truth in addition to force for budget transparency. Moreover, the regents should know this information.
Sources:
You tin determine the total state funding for UC past times combining these:
http://192.234.213.2/sections/econ_fiscal/Historical_Expenditures_Pivot.xls
http://www.cpec.ca.gov/completereports/2004reports/04-20/21.PDF
http://www.cpec.ca.gov/FiscalData/FundingTable.ASP
Enrollment data:
2000 to 2008 here: http://www.universityofcalifornia.edu/accountability/index.php?in=6.2&source=uw
1964 to 2006 here: http://budget.ucop.edu/enroll/actfte.pdf
2009 projections are here: http://repository.ucop.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1000&context=enrllmt_lrp_reports
The average pupil credit hours tin hold upward constitute at: https://sisds.ucdavis.edu/aboutinstruction.htm
Average salaries for professors 2011: http://www.universityofcalifornia.edu/regents/regmeet/jan11/joint.pdf
For the average terms of benefits for faculty serving the center missions, see:
“The University of California 2008-09 Budget For Current Operations Summary of he Budget Request.”
In contrast to pop belief, the UC brings inwards extra revenue for each pupil it enrolls, in addition to therefore, it makes no financial or educational feel to cut back enrollments. In fact, I have got lately presented to the Office of the President a novel calculation of how much the UC profits from each additional student. While I have got non heard dorsum from UCOP yet, my calculations present that the direction has been misrepresenting UC’s financial condition to non entirely Earth in addition to the state, but too to the Regents. As yous volition read below, virtually all of the statistics that UCOP presented at the concluding Regents coming together regarding pupil enrollment in addition to finances are agency off the mark, in addition to this information has led some Regents to believe that the UC tin only surrender on state funding. Moreover, the same faulty information is beingness used past times the Governor to threaten a doubling of pupil tuition.
How Much Does the State Really Give the UC Per Student
The University of California direction oftentimes argues that the state back upward for UC students has gone downwards past times over 50% inwards the concluding xx years, but looking at the actual enrollment in addition to funding numbers (the sources are listed at the halt of this entry), nosotros abide by that the per pupil state funding inwards 1990 was $13,690 (there were 156,000 students in addition to the state gave the UC $2.1 billion). In 2010-11, the per pupil state funding is $15,000 (200,00 resident students in addition to the state funding is $3 billion). In terms of pupil fees in addition to tuition, the UC volition have this twelvemonth $1.9 billion inwards tuition in addition to fees (after paying out financial aid), in addition to at that topographic point are 215,000 students (resident in addition to non resident, graduate, undergraduate, in addition to professional); thus the electrical flow per pupil tuition revenue is $8,267. If the state reduces its back upward to $2.1 billion, which is what the Governor is threatening volition hand off if taxation extensions are non passed, the per pupil state back upward volition hold upward just over $10,000, in addition to the total revenue per pupil volition hold upward most $19,000. Furthermore, if the UC gets $2.6 billion from the state, the per pupil back upward for resident undergraduate in addition to graduate students volition hold upward $13,000. In whatever case, it is wrong to tell that students volition hold upward paying to a greater extent than than the state. In fact, currently, the UC is scheduled to have $21,260 per pupil inwards combined state funds in addition to pupil tuition (this is based on state back upward of $2.6 billion). If nosotros add together inwards an average of $2,080 per pupil out of the full general fund, this gives a total of $23,340 of revenue per pupil (the UCOP 2011-12 budget presentation graph puts this number at $17,220). As I told members of the UCOP budget staff, past times downplaying these numbers, the direction motivates Regents to claim that nosotros tin only walk away from state funding.
How Much Profit Does UC Make on Each Additional Student?
I have got too showed UCOP how the worst affair the UC could practice is to decrease its undergraduate enrollments because my analysis shows that UC makes a net off of undergraduate pupil it enrolls. According to UC’s ain numbers inwards its accountability report, inwards 2007-08, at that topographic point were 3,008 Lecturers (average twenty-four hr menstruation of the month was 51%) representing 1,550 full-time equivalent positions (fte), in addition to they generated 1,554 pupil credit hours per lecturer fte at a terms of $34 per pupil credit hr (the average lecturer FTE salary was $54,000 inwards 2009-10). (I am using the most recent salary information from 2009-2010 in addition to the most recent pupil credit hr data, which is from 2007-08. If anything, faculty are teaching to a greater extent than pupil credit hours now, so my calculations are highly conservative).
If nosotros instantly await at senate faculty, inwards 2007-08, at that topographic point were 10,150 senate faculty FTE averaging 445 pupil credit hours per fte. Senate fauclty had an average salary of $110,000 in addition to terms $247 per pupil credit (student credit hours are a superior agency of calculating terms because they takes into work concern human relationship course of study size in addition to course of study units). Last year, undergraduate students averaged 45 credit hours per year, in addition to since 2 thirds of the pupil credit hours are taught past times senate faculty, nosotros tin calculate that the total straight instructional terms is $7,920; it terms $7,410 for senate faculty to generate thirty pupil credit hours in addition to $510 for lecturers to create xv pupil credit hours. If nosotros add together 20% of salary for benefits, nosotros larn $9,504. (This number is high because one-half of the lecturers practice non larn benefits, in addition to the senate faculty who learn most of the undergraduate courses practice non brand equally much equally the senate faculty teaching to a greater extent than oftentimes than non graduate courses. Also, UC does non count courses taught past times graduate students in addition to instead oftentimes credits graduate pupil taught courses to senate faculty who are the teachers of record, in addition to this inflates the terms since graduate students larn so much less coin than senate faculty).
Using the conservative instructional terms of $9,504 in addition to the electrical flow revenue per pupil of $23,340 (calculated above), the UC generates $13,836 per pupil to pay for related in addition to unrelated costs. It is clear that due to the economies of scale, each fourth dimension yous add together to a greater extent than students, yous practice non hire some other administrator or pay to a greater extent than for utilities, the library, or maintenance, in addition to so it makes no financial feel to cut back enrollments, particularly for lower-division undergraduates who are past times far the to the lowest degree costly students. Also, if yous cut back enrollments, yous practice non have got downwards libraries or halt paying your electrical bills.
Now, if nosotros desire to figure the indirect terms per student, 1 agency to practice this would hold upward to determine how much each campus spends on its center mission. For instance, the UCLA College spends 70% of its full general funds budget on faculty salaries in addition to benefits (this includes senate faculty, lecturers, in addition to grad students) in addition to 16% on staff in addition to 11% on operational expenditures, so the indirect terms is 27-30%. If nosotros have got the conservative indirect terms of 30%, in addition to nosotros add together it to my straight instructional terms per pupil of $9,504, in addition to so the total terms is instantly $12,355. Once again, it makes no financial feel for the UC to cut back enrollment since it brings inwards an extra $10,985 per undergraduate student. In the illustration of nonresident students, the UC brings inwards an extra $23,450 per student. Even if the state decides to cut back UC funding past times a billion dollars adjacent year, the UC volition withal pick out inwards a net of $8,000 per student.
While I am withal working difficult to larn the state non to cutting the UC budget, I too recognize that most of the UC’s financial problems are internal. The quandary is that fifty-fifty though it is irrational for the UC to double tuition if the state doubles its budget cut, I believe this is just what volition hand off because no 1 is dealing alongside actual numbers. We all take away to human face upward the truth in addition to force for budget transparency. Moreover, the regents should know this information.
Sources:
You tin determine the total state funding for UC past times combining these:
http://192.234.213.2/sections/econ_fiscal/Historical_Expenditures_Pivot.xls
http://www.cpec.ca.gov/completereports/2004reports/04-20/21.PDF
http://www.cpec.ca.gov/FiscalData/FundingTable.ASP
Enrollment data:
2000 to 2008 here: http://www.universityofcalifornia.edu/accountability/index.php?in=6.2&source=uw
1964 to 2006 here: http://budget.ucop.edu/enroll/actfte.pdf
2009 projections are here: http://repository.ucop.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1000&context=enrllmt_lrp_reports
The average pupil credit hours tin hold upward constitute at: https://sisds.ucdavis.edu/aboutinstruction.htm
Average salaries for professors 2011: http://www.universityofcalifornia.edu/regents/regmeet/jan11/joint.pdf
For the average terms of benefits for faculty serving the center missions, see:
“The University of California 2008-09 Budget For Current Operations Summary of he Budget Request.”