The Governor, The Uc Budget, Together With Online Education
Thursday, June 26, 2008
Edit
This volition live on a rather long transportation service that volition hash out 2 related topics: Governor Brown’s novel budget for the UC organization together with the Regents coming give-and-take of online education. In terms of the terra firma budget, Brown proposes the following: “The state’s General Fund contribution to UC, CSU, together with Hastings volition increment past times 5 percentage per twelvemonth inwards 2013‑14 together with 2014‑15 together with past times 4 percentage inwards each of the subsequent 2 years.” Although it is a welcomed relief to reckon increased funding for the UC system, it is non closed to the amount that UCOP says the academy needs. According to Brown’s budget statement: “UC together with CSU receive got proposed budgets that telephone telephone for increases inwards terra firma funding of most 12 percentage together with eighteen percent, respectively, from the preceding year. By comparison, over the past times iii years, personal income growth inwards California has averaged slightly less than 4 percentage per year. California taxpayers cannot sustain institutions whose terms growth greatly outpaces the state’s income growth. Furthermore, the rapidly growing numbers of college graduates who are unable to repay their pupil loans is an indication that these costs cannot live on forever pushed onto students through tuition together with fee increases.” In other words, the universities are asking for every bit good much, together with they demand to alive inside their means. Moreover, it is unclear from the budget document if the Governor is basing his increased funding on a hereafter tuition freeze.
What is clear is that Brown feels that the UC tin transportation away practise things inwards a much to a greater extent than efficient together with cost-effective manner: “from 2007‑08 to 2012‑13, when other populace agencies were retrenching, UC expenditures increased past times fifteen percentage together with CSU expenditures increased past times 3 percent. These expenditure increases were funded past times about $1.4 billion inwards tuition revenue increases at UC together with $1 billion at CSU, a close doubling of tuition together with fees from 2007‑08 to the present. Specifically, UC’s tuition together with fees increased past times $5,556 over that period. CSU’s tuition together with fees increased past times $2,700 over that same menses (see Figure HED‑01). These rapid tuition increases receive got been a meaning hardship for students together with their families, specially middle‑income families who practise non qualify for Cal Grants.” Thus, piece the governor realizes that tuition increases receive got been inwards utilization the outcome of terra firma budget funding for higher ed, he also thinks the universities demand to practise a meliorate chore at reducing their expenses.
Brown believes that every bit good many students are non graduating inwards a timely fashion, together with hence the UC organization has to practise several things: halt students from taking extra credits, cut down tuition increases, brand to a greater extent than classes available, together with brand the delivery of instruction less costly. To cook many of these problems, he wants to plough to technology: “All institutions volition live on expected to utilization these increases to implement reforms that volition brand available the courses students demand together with aid them progress through college efficiently, using engineering to deliver character didactics to greater numbers of students inwards high‑demand courses, improving course of study direction together with planning, using faculty to a greater extent than effectively, together with increasing utilization of summertime sessions. With savings achieved inwards this way, inwards combination amongst the General Fund increases together with realizing the savings of electrical current efficiency efforts (e.g. UC’s Working Smarter Initiative together with CSU’s Systemwide Administrative Efficiencies), the Administration expects the colleges together with universities to maintain electrical current tuition together with fee levels over the side past times side iv years.” Governor Brown is controversy hither that due to the combination of increased terra firma funding together with the utilization of novel technologies, the UC should non demand to heighten tuition. In fact, he wants to aid fund the UC online program: “the Budget provides UC together with CSU $10 1000000 each to increment the set out of courses available to matriculated undergraduates through the utilization of technology, specifically those courses that receive got the highest demand, fill upwardly quickly, together with are prerequisites for many dissimilar degrees. Priority volition live on given to the evolution of courses that tin transportation away serve greater numbers of students piece providing equal or meliorate learning experiences.” Since the UC is already planning to pass $7 1000000 on its failing online airplane pilot program, the governor may live on truly bailing out a bad persuasion together with doubling downward on the online gamble.
The Governor also extends the online panacea to the community college system, where he envisions the next utilization of technology: “This first volition include iii key elements: (1) the creation of a “virtual campus” to increment statewide pupil access to 250 novel courses delivered through technology, (2) the creation of a single, common, together with centralized delivery together with back upwardly infrastructure for all courses delivered through engineering together with for all colleges, together with (3) the expansion of options for students to access instruction inwards other environments together with earn college credit for demonstrated cognition together with skills through credit past times exam.” This strategy brings together some of the worst ideas circulating inwards higher education: let’s practise virtual campuses for the most disadvantaged students every bit nosotros hold to supersede traditional courses amongst a wide-range of substitutes.
Once again, I should stress that I am inwards favor of using novel technologies to increment the effectiveness of academy education, but at that topographic point is no proof that this volition salvage money, together with it fails to bargain amongst the existent cost-drivers, which are administration, construction, sponsored-research together with graduate together with professional person education. This failure to empathise the existent spending streams inwards higher ed is also evident inwards the UC Online projection report that has been developed for the side past times side UC Regents meeting. In a virtual re-create of the Governor’s ain give-and-take of how novel technologies volition salvage higher education, nosotros uncovering the next declaration most the UC online program: “Anticipated benefits from for-credit online undergraduate courses include additional opportunities for high-quality instruction throughout the UC system, decreased time-to-degree, increased pupil success, together with decreased costs of instruction. Future directions include streamlining cross-campus together with systemwide processes, increasing enrollment inwards for-credit online undergraduate courses, using innovative learning technology, enrolling non-UC students, together with establishing feasible long-term fiscal models together with short-term investments.” As nosotros volition read afterwards on, the initial give-and-take of saving coin through online didactics is centered on a telephone telephone to increment funding for online initiatives: “It is clear straightaway that both the campuses together with UCOE would practise goodness from an infusion of funding on a temporary set down to facilitate continued development. The cross-campus hub needs to live on developed, together with at that topographic point is currently no budgeted fund source. Additional instructional designers for UCOE together with instructional designers at the campuses would greatly increment the charge per unit of measurement of creation of novel online courses, the improvement of existing online courses, together with the displace of courses to blessing for both academic-year together with summertime offering together with and then to systemwide approval. Current estimates are that an instructional designer tin transportation away develop iii to iv courses per year, supply a major update for iii to iv courses already offered per year, together with supply a tike update to several courses per year. Several campuses, if non all, together with to a lesser extent UCOE would also practise goodness from additional equipment together with facilities for the production of online, hybrid, together with technology-assisted courses together with from a fund for the short-term contracting out of detail evolution tasks. UC volition hold to elaborate on resources needs every bit campus plans together with systemwide goals acquire clearer.” Let’s see, nosotros are going to salvage coin past times finding coin to fund course of study developers, technological hubs, novel equipment, novel facilities, together with outsourced evolution people. As I receive got previously written, in 1 lawsuit yous firstly to receive got into concern human relationship all of the expenses related to developing an effective online program, yous chop-chop run upwardly the tab.
Like the expanding sponsored query mission, it is difficult for online programs to pay for all of their related costs. It exactly seems similar yous never receive got plenty administrators together with staff every bit yous force to downsize the faculty. If yous retrieve I am existence paranoid here, allow us facial expression at 1 of the ideas for replacing electrical current courses taught past times regular UC Faculty: “some of the Extension XB, XD, etc. online courses mightiness live on considered for blessing every bit courses to live on offered during regular terms together with systemwide if the course of study is appropriate together with is non currently offered online to UC students.” In other terms, to a greater extent than students volition live on able to acquire UC course of study credit for extension courses that are oft taught past times non-UC faculty. In fact, the extension teachers practise non receive got benefits, chore security, academic freedom, fair compensation, or the same credentials every bit UC faculty who learn inwards the “regular” programs.
Moreover, the other way that the UC thinks it tin transportation away salvage coin is past times using novel technologies to exactly expand the size of classes together with eliminate the demand for the faculty: “The increased enrollment capacity possible amongst online for-credit courses could outcome inwards a cost-savings to campus departments. An on-ground course of study that enrolls 100 students may require an instructor together with 2 teaching assistants (TAs). To learn 500 students, the subdivision would receive got to offering together with encompass the instructional costs of offering the course of study 5 times. An online course of study could enroll 500 students inwards 1 offering; it may all the same require the same set out of TAs, 10 inwards this example, but it volition salvage the subdivision inwards instructor expenses together with time.” Not solely mightiness this model salvage the subdivision money, but it may also eliminate the jobs of most of the faculty members.
The fantasy underlying most of these proposals is a high-tech academy staffed amongst high-paying administrators together with exploited graduate students. With large online courses together with graduate pupil assistants, at that topographic point is no demand to hire to a greater extent than faculty members. Furthermore, every bit I receive got stressed elsewhere, undergraduate instruction is the most cost-effective utilization of the university, together with hence instead of turning their attending to the existent causes for increased costs, the management wants to standardized the curriculum together with develop system-wide courses: “UC is developing a machinery that volition easily allow UC students to receive got courses at campuses other than the 1 inwards which they matriculated. This cross-campus enrollment physical care for volition allow UC students to receive got total payoff of 1 of the key benefits of online courses – the chance to acquire from experts exterior their ain campus.” The employment amongst this notion is that in 1 lawsuit departments lose their cash cows--lower-division undergrad courses--there is no demand to fund these programs.
UC argues that 1 surface area of potential savings could come upwardly past times lowering the demand to build to a greater extent than classrooms: “Online courses also allow the academy to enroll students without the proportional demand for novel uppercase projects. It would terms the University about $1.8 billion to build the brick together with mortar infrastructure needed to serve 11,000 novel full-time equivalent students. The online infrastructure required to back upwardly the same set out of students would terms about $20 million, a savings of over $1.7 billion. Because online courses volition non require classroom space, greater adoption of online instruction tin transportation away alleviate some classroom scheduling constraints together with some demand for novel instructional space.” This seems to brand sense, unless yous know that during the recent surge inwards UC enrollments really few novel classrooms receive got been added. Instead, the UC spends its coin edifice medical facilities, query centers, together with dorms.
In an apparent nod to the faculty, the study does offering a way for professors to brand to a greater extent than money: “UC volition undoubtedly hold to position how it tin transportation away leverage electrical current together with evolving trends inwards innovative learning engineering to practise goodness UC students together with faculty. One aspect of this mightiness live on to encourage UC faculty to develop MOOCs amongst the diverse for-profit or non-profit groups piece simultaneously working to develop ways to supply UC credit for MOOC students either currently at UC or amongst intentions to enroll at UC. This mightiness live on accomplished past times developing specific exams for electrical current or hereafter students to receive got that would certify a competency appropriate for UC credit or past times adding additional learning activities together with instructor involvement that rounds out the MOOC experience inwards ways that brand the totality eligible for UC course of study credit.” I read this passage every bit proverb the faculty tin transportation away brand some extra coin past times selling their courses to other content providers, piece the UC saves coin past times giving course of study credits for online classes developed past times exterior providers. So allow me acquire this vision right: UC faculty halt teaching UC courses every bit UC students firstly getting credit for courses developed exterior of the UC system; meanwhile, the remaining UC faculty could increment their earnings past times selling their courses to the highest external bidder every bit UC courses are outsourced to other providers.
But what most quality? Here is the best trace from the whole report: “The Academic Senate has established procedures together with criteria at all campuses that consider the unique aspects of online courses, together with the Senate’s systemwide University Committee on Educational Policy (UCEP) has established guidelines for extending the blessing physical care for to brand campus-approved courses available systemwide. Early information from the Senate’s requested UCOE evaluation are that courses are successful, valued, together with “high character curriculum.” Similar evaluations of campus-produced online courses would undoubtedly yield similar results.” According to this circular logic, since the past times courses receive got been deemed high quality, the novel classes volition “undoubtedly” live on high quality. This trace of thinking does non increment my faith inwards the powerfulness of the academy to maintain educational quality.
At 1 point, the study does recognize that virtually all of its previous predictions concerning the airplane pilot online programme receive got failed: “When the master copy marketing study was done xvi months ago, at that topographic point were relatively favorable indications of involvement inwards enrolling inwards UC for-credit, for-fee online courses inside California, together with many of the online options available straightaway were non inwards house or fifty-fifty envisioned. For a set out of reasons, evolution of online courses inwards UCOE is about half dozen months behind the master copy schedule, but the set out of course of study offerings that could enroll non-matriculated students for 2013-14 exceeds the master copy budget planning assumptions. However, projections every bit to the marketplace for these courses may plough out to receive got been overly optimistic.” This is an understatement since nosotros straightaway know that UC has spent $5 1000000 to enroll 5 students together with non the planned 3,000 non-UC students. And yet, it looks similar the terra firma volition bail out the UC online airplane pilot programme hence they tin transportation away double downward on their delusional bet. We all demand to educate the governor together with the regents most the realities of this online venture.
What is clear is that Brown feels that the UC tin transportation away practise things inwards a much to a greater extent than efficient together with cost-effective manner: “from 2007‑08 to 2012‑13, when other populace agencies were retrenching, UC expenditures increased past times fifteen percentage together with CSU expenditures increased past times 3 percent. These expenditure increases were funded past times about $1.4 billion inwards tuition revenue increases at UC together with $1 billion at CSU, a close doubling of tuition together with fees from 2007‑08 to the present. Specifically, UC’s tuition together with fees increased past times $5,556 over that period. CSU’s tuition together with fees increased past times $2,700 over that same menses (see Figure HED‑01). These rapid tuition increases receive got been a meaning hardship for students together with their families, specially middle‑income families who practise non qualify for Cal Grants.” Thus, piece the governor realizes that tuition increases receive got been inwards utilization the outcome of terra firma budget funding for higher ed, he also thinks the universities demand to practise a meliorate chore at reducing their expenses.
Brown believes that every bit good many students are non graduating inwards a timely fashion, together with hence the UC organization has to practise several things: halt students from taking extra credits, cut down tuition increases, brand to a greater extent than classes available, together with brand the delivery of instruction less costly. To cook many of these problems, he wants to plough to technology: “All institutions volition live on expected to utilization these increases to implement reforms that volition brand available the courses students demand together with aid them progress through college efficiently, using engineering to deliver character didactics to greater numbers of students inwards high‑demand courses, improving course of study direction together with planning, using faculty to a greater extent than effectively, together with increasing utilization of summertime sessions. With savings achieved inwards this way, inwards combination amongst the General Fund increases together with realizing the savings of electrical current efficiency efforts (e.g. UC’s Working Smarter Initiative together with CSU’s Systemwide Administrative Efficiencies), the Administration expects the colleges together with universities to maintain electrical current tuition together with fee levels over the side past times side iv years.” Governor Brown is controversy hither that due to the combination of increased terra firma funding together with the utilization of novel technologies, the UC should non demand to heighten tuition. In fact, he wants to aid fund the UC online program: “the Budget provides UC together with CSU $10 1000000 each to increment the set out of courses available to matriculated undergraduates through the utilization of technology, specifically those courses that receive got the highest demand, fill upwardly quickly, together with are prerequisites for many dissimilar degrees. Priority volition live on given to the evolution of courses that tin transportation away serve greater numbers of students piece providing equal or meliorate learning experiences.” Since the UC is already planning to pass $7 1000000 on its failing online airplane pilot program, the governor may live on truly bailing out a bad persuasion together with doubling downward on the online gamble.
The Governor also extends the online panacea to the community college system, where he envisions the next utilization of technology: “This first volition include iii key elements: (1) the creation of a “virtual campus” to increment statewide pupil access to 250 novel courses delivered through technology, (2) the creation of a single, common, together with centralized delivery together with back upwardly infrastructure for all courses delivered through engineering together with for all colleges, together with (3) the expansion of options for students to access instruction inwards other environments together with earn college credit for demonstrated cognition together with skills through credit past times exam.” This strategy brings together some of the worst ideas circulating inwards higher education: let’s practise virtual campuses for the most disadvantaged students every bit nosotros hold to supersede traditional courses amongst a wide-range of substitutes.
Once again, I should stress that I am inwards favor of using novel technologies to increment the effectiveness of academy education, but at that topographic point is no proof that this volition salvage money, together with it fails to bargain amongst the existent cost-drivers, which are administration, construction, sponsored-research together with graduate together with professional person education. This failure to empathise the existent spending streams inwards higher ed is also evident inwards the UC Online projection report that has been developed for the side past times side UC Regents meeting. In a virtual re-create of the Governor’s ain give-and-take of how novel technologies volition salvage higher education, nosotros uncovering the next declaration most the UC online program: “Anticipated benefits from for-credit online undergraduate courses include additional opportunities for high-quality instruction throughout the UC system, decreased time-to-degree, increased pupil success, together with decreased costs of instruction. Future directions include streamlining cross-campus together with systemwide processes, increasing enrollment inwards for-credit online undergraduate courses, using innovative learning technology, enrolling non-UC students, together with establishing feasible long-term fiscal models together with short-term investments.” As nosotros volition read afterwards on, the initial give-and-take of saving coin through online didactics is centered on a telephone telephone to increment funding for online initiatives: “It is clear straightaway that both the campuses together with UCOE would practise goodness from an infusion of funding on a temporary set down to facilitate continued development. The cross-campus hub needs to live on developed, together with at that topographic point is currently no budgeted fund source. Additional instructional designers for UCOE together with instructional designers at the campuses would greatly increment the charge per unit of measurement of creation of novel online courses, the improvement of existing online courses, together with the displace of courses to blessing for both academic-year together with summertime offering together with and then to systemwide approval. Current estimates are that an instructional designer tin transportation away develop iii to iv courses per year, supply a major update for iii to iv courses already offered per year, together with supply a tike update to several courses per year. Several campuses, if non all, together with to a lesser extent UCOE would also practise goodness from additional equipment together with facilities for the production of online, hybrid, together with technology-assisted courses together with from a fund for the short-term contracting out of detail evolution tasks. UC volition hold to elaborate on resources needs every bit campus plans together with systemwide goals acquire clearer.” Let’s see, nosotros are going to salvage coin past times finding coin to fund course of study developers, technological hubs, novel equipment, novel facilities, together with outsourced evolution people. As I receive got previously written, in 1 lawsuit yous firstly to receive got into concern human relationship all of the expenses related to developing an effective online program, yous chop-chop run upwardly the tab.
Like the expanding sponsored query mission, it is difficult for online programs to pay for all of their related costs. It exactly seems similar yous never receive got plenty administrators together with staff every bit yous force to downsize the faculty. If yous retrieve I am existence paranoid here, allow us facial expression at 1 of the ideas for replacing electrical current courses taught past times regular UC Faculty: “some of the Extension XB, XD, etc. online courses mightiness live on considered for blessing every bit courses to live on offered during regular terms together with systemwide if the course of study is appropriate together with is non currently offered online to UC students.” In other terms, to a greater extent than students volition live on able to acquire UC course of study credit for extension courses that are oft taught past times non-UC faculty. In fact, the extension teachers practise non receive got benefits, chore security, academic freedom, fair compensation, or the same credentials every bit UC faculty who learn inwards the “regular” programs.
Moreover, the other way that the UC thinks it tin transportation away salvage coin is past times using novel technologies to exactly expand the size of classes together with eliminate the demand for the faculty: “The increased enrollment capacity possible amongst online for-credit courses could outcome inwards a cost-savings to campus departments. An on-ground course of study that enrolls 100 students may require an instructor together with 2 teaching assistants (TAs). To learn 500 students, the subdivision would receive got to offering together with encompass the instructional costs of offering the course of study 5 times. An online course of study could enroll 500 students inwards 1 offering; it may all the same require the same set out of TAs, 10 inwards this example, but it volition salvage the subdivision inwards instructor expenses together with time.” Not solely mightiness this model salvage the subdivision money, but it may also eliminate the jobs of most of the faculty members.
The fantasy underlying most of these proposals is a high-tech academy staffed amongst high-paying administrators together with exploited graduate students. With large online courses together with graduate pupil assistants, at that topographic point is no demand to hire to a greater extent than faculty members. Furthermore, every bit I receive got stressed elsewhere, undergraduate instruction is the most cost-effective utilization of the university, together with hence instead of turning their attending to the existent causes for increased costs, the management wants to standardized the curriculum together with develop system-wide courses: “UC is developing a machinery that volition easily allow UC students to receive got courses at campuses other than the 1 inwards which they matriculated. This cross-campus enrollment physical care for volition allow UC students to receive got total payoff of 1 of the key benefits of online courses – the chance to acquire from experts exterior their ain campus.” The employment amongst this notion is that in 1 lawsuit departments lose their cash cows--lower-division undergrad courses--there is no demand to fund these programs.
UC argues that 1 surface area of potential savings could come upwardly past times lowering the demand to build to a greater extent than classrooms: “Online courses also allow the academy to enroll students without the proportional demand for novel uppercase projects. It would terms the University about $1.8 billion to build the brick together with mortar infrastructure needed to serve 11,000 novel full-time equivalent students. The online infrastructure required to back upwardly the same set out of students would terms about $20 million, a savings of over $1.7 billion. Because online courses volition non require classroom space, greater adoption of online instruction tin transportation away alleviate some classroom scheduling constraints together with some demand for novel instructional space.” This seems to brand sense, unless yous know that during the recent surge inwards UC enrollments really few novel classrooms receive got been added. Instead, the UC spends its coin edifice medical facilities, query centers, together with dorms.
In an apparent nod to the faculty, the study does offering a way for professors to brand to a greater extent than money: “UC volition undoubtedly hold to position how it tin transportation away leverage electrical current together with evolving trends inwards innovative learning engineering to practise goodness UC students together with faculty. One aspect of this mightiness live on to encourage UC faculty to develop MOOCs amongst the diverse for-profit or non-profit groups piece simultaneously working to develop ways to supply UC credit for MOOC students either currently at UC or amongst intentions to enroll at UC. This mightiness live on accomplished past times developing specific exams for electrical current or hereafter students to receive got that would certify a competency appropriate for UC credit or past times adding additional learning activities together with instructor involvement that rounds out the MOOC experience inwards ways that brand the totality eligible for UC course of study credit.” I read this passage every bit proverb the faculty tin transportation away brand some extra coin past times selling their courses to other content providers, piece the UC saves coin past times giving course of study credits for online classes developed past times exterior providers. So allow me acquire this vision right: UC faculty halt teaching UC courses every bit UC students firstly getting credit for courses developed exterior of the UC system; meanwhile, the remaining UC faculty could increment their earnings past times selling their courses to the highest external bidder every bit UC courses are outsourced to other providers.
But what most quality? Here is the best trace from the whole report: “The Academic Senate has established procedures together with criteria at all campuses that consider the unique aspects of online courses, together with the Senate’s systemwide University Committee on Educational Policy (UCEP) has established guidelines for extending the blessing physical care for to brand campus-approved courses available systemwide. Early information from the Senate’s requested UCOE evaluation are that courses are successful, valued, together with “high character curriculum.” Similar evaluations of campus-produced online courses would undoubtedly yield similar results.” According to this circular logic, since the past times courses receive got been deemed high quality, the novel classes volition “undoubtedly” live on high quality. This trace of thinking does non increment my faith inwards the powerfulness of the academy to maintain educational quality.
At 1 point, the study does recognize that virtually all of its previous predictions concerning the airplane pilot online programme receive got failed: “When the master copy marketing study was done xvi months ago, at that topographic point were relatively favorable indications of involvement inwards enrolling inwards UC for-credit, for-fee online courses inside California, together with many of the online options available straightaway were non inwards house or fifty-fifty envisioned. For a set out of reasons, evolution of online courses inwards UCOE is about half dozen months behind the master copy schedule, but the set out of course of study offerings that could enroll non-matriculated students for 2013-14 exceeds the master copy budget planning assumptions. However, projections every bit to the marketplace for these courses may plough out to receive got been overly optimistic.” This is an understatement since nosotros straightaway know that UC has spent $5 1000000 to enroll 5 students together with non the planned 3,000 non-UC students. And yet, it looks similar the terra firma volition bail out the UC online airplane pilot programme hence they tin transportation away double downward on their delusional bet. We all demand to educate the governor together with the regents most the realities of this online venture.