The Zombie Bill: Sb520 Passes Out Of The Senate
Sunday, June 1, 2008
Edit
In the brief debate (go to the 3:06:00 mark) over the bill, 1 tin take away heed all of the measure rhetorical moves that dominate the electrical flow conversation regarding high-tech solutions to diverse social problems. Senator Steinberg begins his defence of the SB520 yesteryear stressing that online educational activity is non a magic bullet that volition solve all of the problems caused yesteryear years of nation budget cuts to higher education; however, he speedily changes administration when he quotes 2 paper articles touting Coursera’s recent bargain alongside several nation higher educational activity systems. In pointing to this latest development, he stresses that California cannot hold upwards left behind inward this novel race to amend access as well as affordability through distance education.
This notion that nosotros cannot hold upwards left behind inward this high-tech race is a reoccurring subject heard throughout the populace as well as political debate. The thought hither is that fifty-fifty if the costs as well as effects of digital educational activity are soundless unknown, nosotros must exercise it because others are doing it. According to this grouping psychology, nosotros must follow the crowd as well as ignore our ain doubts as well as questions. For instance, fifty-fifty though about professors experience that this motility to online courses volition trim back the number of faculty positions, Steinberg assures the faculty that this is non the intention of the bill, yet, it is of import to betoken out that inward the context of social psychology, private intentions exercise non matter. In fact, 1 of the start senators to verbalise inward back upwards of the bill, Wyland, intoned that nosotros must realize that in that place is non going to hold upwards coin to hire to a greater extent than professors, as well as then the exactly agency to amend access is to exercise it online.
From Wyland’s Republican perspective, the downsizing of faculty is a given, as well as all populace functions volition receive got to exercise to a greater extent than alongside less. This fatalistic logic is inherent to the promoters of high-tech solutions: from their perspective, resistance is futile, as well as nosotros cannot halt the “natural” progress of technological as well as economical change. Of course, Wyland as well as the other Republicans who all voted alongside Steinberg exhibit the bipartisan nature of this high-tech rhetoric: the Republican wishing to shrink big authorities as well as privatize populace institutions has joined hands alongside the Democratic postulate to hold upwards associated alongside progress as well as private-public articulation ventures.
The Democrats as well as Republicans are besides able to bring together together because they both encompass the imitation rhetoric of student-centered digital education. While it is clear why the libertarian Right would similar to plough higher educational activity into a private affair pursued yesteryear private individuals preferably inward the privacy of their ain homes, it is less clear why the Democrats receive got taken the libertarian student-centered bait. However, Senator’s Torrez’s remarks shed about low-cal on the issue. She argues that the exactly agency she was able to graduate as well as larn her grade from the national labor college was due to the fact that she could accept all of her classes online. The start thing to betoken out hither is that the “liberal” national labor college has late sold off its campus as well as is right away exactly online. Thus, inward the peachy tradition of Clintonian triangulation, a schoolhouse dedicated to labor issues promotes a labor-destroying system; meanwhile students are celebrated equally their futures are de-funded.
Whether it is intentional or not, the existent driving strength behind online educational activity is the farther dismantling of the teaching profession as well as the marketization of populace institutions.